Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Proven Strategies and Experience. Your Goals.

$260MILLION+

Sold Since 2020

386

Properties Sold

$100MILLION+

Waterfront Sold Since 2020

main

Carly Sostheim

is a seasoned real estate professional, blending an unwavering dedication to genuine connections with a profound wealth of industry knowledge. With over $260 million in sales since 2020, Carly's impressive track record speaks volumes about her expertise and dedication to her clients.

Anna Catherine Miller Panama City, FL Real Estate Agent Headshot

Anna Catherine

has been an integral part of Carly’s success, serving as an Executive Assistant over the last two years. She manages the day-to-day operations and provides a level of service to Carly’s clients that complements Carly’s strong sense of relationship-driven customer service. 

Real Stories, Real Results

Kim D.

Kim D.

My sister and I had the daunting task of selling our parents' waterfront house of 42 years. Having never lived in Panama City ourselves, we were not familiar with the market or how to price the home in an area without many comp...
Read More
Kelly H.

Kelly H.

Carly is the best of the best! We couldn't have asked for a better experience! She and her team made the entire process of selling our home so easy and seamless from start to finish. Carly is extremely knowledgeable about the a...
Read More
Kirra O.

Kirra O.

We have had the pleasure of working with Carly over the last 6 months, and she is nothing short of incredible. She doesn’t stop until she’s found what you’re looking for. She goes above and beyond from start to closing and is t...
Read More
Kurt B.

Kurt B.

We have bought two homes in the last two years with the professional, insightful help of Carly! Hands down, she’s the best and a straight shooter!
Read More
Adam P.

Adam P.

Carly is one of the best in the business. She helped us get into our new home and sell our old one. The new home was a complicated buy since it was still under construction when we signed our contract. There were many moving pa...
Read More
Chastain L.

Chastain L.

Carly is the best realtor we've ever worked with. She is so knowledgeable not only on real estate but also on the Panama City Area as a whole. She was able to answer every single question we had and was available to us every st...
Read More
Karen B.

Karen B.

Carly was terrific in helping us sell my Mom's house, so when it was time to put our house on the market, there was no other choice for us! Carly worked with us to make sure we were able to highlight all of the great things tha...
Read More
Kelly F.

Kelly F.

We have worked with Carly several times, and she always goes out of her way to make the process as smooth and painless as possible. Whether buying or selling, she answers every question and is proactive to make sure everything ...
Read More
Elizabeth H.

Elizabeth H.

Carly was so easy to work with! I was nervous to sell my first home and was full of questions. She answered them all and never made me feel like any question was silly. She was always extremely responsive, no matter the day of ...
Read More
Will C.

Will C.

Absolutely wonderful to work with. Excellent communication and hustle throughout the entire buying process. She was very helpful and had resources I didn’t even know I needed! I would love to work with Carly again and highly re...
Read More
Michael G.

Michael G.

My wife and I have worked with Carly on two occasions. The first was to sell our vacation home, and the second was to buy a new one. Both times we had a great experience. Carly is very knowledgeable, professional, and personabl...
Read More
Luke W.

Luke W.

Carly did a fantastic job selling our home. She is always very responsive and goes out of her way to make sure the process goes as smoothly as possible. As a local of the area since birth, she knows everyone, which pays off big...
Read More
Collen P.

Collen P.

While we could have done without the missing UPS notarized overnighted paperwork (which was completely out of our hands), we would not have changed a single thing. Carly had photos of our home and listed our property within hou...
Read More
Anne H.

Anne H.

I can’t say enough about Carly Sostheim as a Realtor®. She goes all out to find a buyer, then to help you get together whatever the buyer requests once a contract is executed. She does all of the work for you with as little inc...
Read More

How Much is Your Home Worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more
Your Personal Real Estate Guides

Your Personal Real Estate Guides

Your all-in-one guide to buying or selling a home—expert insights, step-by-step support, and smart strategies to help you move with confidence.

Work With Us

Whether you’re buying or selling, we can assist with determining property value, negotiating deals, drafting contracts, and ensuring a seamless process from start to finish.

Follow Us on Instagram